good design, bad design

The rantings of an engineer …

An engineer’s life is cursed by the demons of bad design, and blessed with glimpses of good design. This week brought both in the area of remote controls.

I had guests over on Saturday, and they brought kids. While placating the juniors with Muppet Show DVDs, I discovered the remote no longer seemed to control the player. This, of course, made me unhappy.

I pushed play and went back to my guests. I can monkey with this later.

Sunday had me swapping AAA batteries out of the DVD remote, but the plastic box still refused to command its counterpart. This set of batteries had been tested, so I was faced with a dead remote … a dead remote for a DVD player I bought in Taipei …

Well, I never did like that remote anyway …

The problem of one dead toy can often be solved with a new toy. My living room, cursed with piles of remotes that won’t talk to each other, needed help. So I bought a Logitech Harmony programmable remote, hoping the need to replace ailing DVD remote would also save me from button overload.

This thing is cool. Open the package, install some software, plug the remote into my PC, run the setup … now everything talks to one remote (even the SLIMP3 and an ancient Samsung VCR). A little fine tuning ensued to customize the remote, but it took very little time and almost no effort.

Now one button fires up the entire home theater setup. If I get really clever, I can get some X10 remotes and make popcorn without getting off the couch (okay, maybe not).

So the Harmony is good design … let’s talk bad design …

When I was opening the Harmony remote package, I noticed it came with 4 Panasonic AAA batteries. Curious, I put them into my ‘ailing’ DVD remote …

And it worked, like magic …

The confused engineer in me, the one who tested the Toshiba batteries before putting them in the remote, was now very intrigued. So I examined the batteries more closely.

The problem was a matter of a millimeters.

The negative end of the Panasonic battery was just a bit thicker than the Toshiba, making the battery longer. The shorter Panasonic battery didn’t put as much pressure on the battery spring … poor contact, no conductivity, no juice.

So the bad design of some cheap-ass battery leads me to the well-designed replacement remote control.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

3 responses to “good design, bad design”

  1. Joyous Avatar
    Joyous

    I wonder if this is the problem I’m having with my garage door remote–hey, can your new remote be programmed for the garage door as well? That would be cool, open the door _and_ turn on the DVD player at the same time! (Not useful, but somehow cool…)

  2. Chris Avatar

    Brian, I’ve been eyeing one of those Harmony remotes for a while myself. Which model did you get?

  3. Mary Crowell Avatar

    *grins* Glad we could help . . .er

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *